The front of a bag is marketing. The back, with its tiny print, is where you actually find out what you are feeding your pet. Once you know what to look for, reading a label takes less than a minute.
Ingredients are listed by weight
Manufacturers must list ingredients in descending order by weight, before cooking. That means the first two or three items make up most of the food. If the list opens with a named meat and a couple of recognisable ingredients, that is a good sign. If it opens with several types of grain or starch before any protein source appears, the food is mostly filler.
Named meat vs vague terms
"Chicken", "salmon" or "beef" refer to a specific animal and are far more informative than "meat", "poultry" or "animal derivatives", which can mean almost anything and vary batch to batch. "Meat meal" (for example "chicken meal") is not automatically bad, it is a concentrated protein source with the water removed, but it should still name the animal. Be cautious with foods where every protein source is generic. This matters even more if your pet has a known sensitivity, in the same way it is worth knowing which foods and plants are dangerous for pets before anything reaches the bowl.
Guaranteed analysis: protein, fat, fibre, moisture
This block gives minimums for protein and fat and maximums for fibre and moisture, not exact values. It also does not tell you the quality of the protein, only the quantity. Use it to compare similar products (dry to dry, wet to wet), not to judge a food on its own. Comparing dry and wet food directly is misleading because wet food is mostly water; if you need to, convert to a dry-matter basis first.
Additives and preservatives
Vitamins and minerals listed at the end are normal and necessary. What is worth a closer look is the preservative used: natural options like mixed tocopherols (a form of vitamin E) are generally preferred over synthetic ones like BHA, BHT or ethoxyquin. Artificial colours are there for the owner's eye, not the pet's, since most pets do not care what colour a kibble is.
Marketing words that mean less than they sound
"Natural", "premium", "holistic" and even "grain-free" are largely unregulated marketing terms and are not a substitute for reading the actual ingredient and analysis panels. Grain-free in particular is not automatically healthier: it simply replaces grain with another starch such as potato or pea, and does not by itself say anything about protein quality.
Check the life-stage statement
Look for a line saying the food is "complete and balanced" for a specific life stage: growth (puppies/kittens), adult maintenance, or all life stages. This statement, tied to AAFCO or FEDIAF standards, matters more than most marketing claims, because it confirms the food was formulated to meet full nutritional needs rather than sold as a treat or topper. Getting the amount right matters too, so pair label-reading with an actual feeding calculation for your dog or a portion guide for your cat.
A quick way to compare two bags
Line up the first five ingredients of each, check whether the protein sources are named, and compare the guaranteed analysis on a dry-matter basis. That alone will tell you more than any claim printed on the front of the bag.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is "by-product" always bad? No. Named by-products (like "chicken by-product") include nutritious parts such as organs and are used in many reputable foods. The real red flag is unnamed "meat by-products" with no species specified.
Does grain-free mean better? Not automatically. It just swaps grain for another carbohydrate source and says nothing on its own about protein quality.
What matters more, ingredient list or guaranteed analysis? Use both together: the ingredient list shows sourcing and quality signals, the guaranteed analysis shows the nutrient minimums and maximums.
No time to compare every label? Flat4Pet sitters can help with feeding routines and day-to-day pet care. Book in the app.
Book trusted, verified London caregivers in seconds.
